Mugshot Galleries Lack Diversity

Too many “black and brown people”

“…mugshot galleries… disproportionately feature black and brown people…”

This has to have something to do with systemic racism.

Screenshot_2020-07-04 PSP Ten Most Wanted - psp_most_wanted_current pdf

Some context for Angel Colon:

The Pennsylvania State Police, Troop N, Hazleton and the Hazleton City Police Department continue their search for Angel E. Colon. Angel E. Colon is wanted for a 2001 Rape and Sexual Abuse of a 10 year old female. This occurred from January 1, 2001 through August 19, 2002, in Hazleton, Luzerne County, PA. Angel E. Colon’s whereabouts are unknown; he has ties to New York City and the Dominican Republic. Colon absconded immediately prior to the start of his trial when his bail was reduced.

Sourced via CRIMEWATCH®:

Screenshot_2020-07-04 05182018_10_Most_wanted_homicide 2e16d0ba fill-735x490 jpg (JPEG Image, 735 × 490 pixels)

Tampa Bay Times, Orlando Sentinel, Gannett Newspapers Stop Publishing Mugshot Galleries

Several media outlets have ended this practice, arguing that mugshot galleries in particular disproportionately feature black and brown people and further negative stereotypes

J. Clara Chan | June 15, 2020 @ 12:37 PM

The Tampa Bay Times, the Orlando Sentinel and 26 former GateHouse newspapers — now owned by Gannett — have ended the practice of publishing arrest mugshot galleries.

“The galleries lack context and further negative stereotypes,” Mark Katches, executive editor of the Tampa Bay Times, said on Monday. “We think the data is an important resource that our newsroom will continue to analyze and watch carefully, but the galleries alone serve little journalistic purpose.”

The Times will still publish mugshots of those arrested for relevant crime stories, however.

The Sentinel also announced last Friday it would be discontinuing its mugshot database because “the galleries have little journalistic value and may have reinforced negative stereotypes.”

Meanwhile, prior to its merger with GateHouse, Gannett had already taken down the mugshot galleries for its papers in 2018. But as of last week, Gannett removed the galleries from 26 papers formerly under the GateHouse umbrella, according to Poynter.

A spokesperson for Gannett did not immediately respond to TheWrap’s request for comment.

“Mugshot galleries presented without context may feed into negative stereotypes and, in our editorial judgment, are of limited news value. Instead, we will focus on the best ways to inform our readers by providing relevant information that will keep our communities safe and continuing to cover crime, as well as the public safety system,” Gannett said in a statement, according to Poynter. “This policy change does not impact the use of mugshots associated with articles or other editorial content.”

Several media outlets had previously ended this practice, also arguing that mugshot galleries in particular disproportionately feature black and brown people and further negative stereotypes. Earlier this year, the Houston Chronicle and stopped publishing their mugshot galleries.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s